The Telegraph: Mid Staffs NHS trust: Why is nobody being punished for this disaster?
Between January 2005 and March 2009, the Mid Staffordshire hospital was a terrible place, where patients were left lying for hours in their urine and faeces. Those who tried to get out of bed and help themselves often fell, and their injuries went unrecorded. You see, old people drinking out of flower vases because nurse won’t bring water are of no concern. Not if you want to hit your targets and achieve the holy grail of Foundation Trust, which Mid Staffordshire most definitely did.
I wrote a few days ago:
Did things just happen or was there a master plan?
The NHS has been subjected to reform, re-reform and re-re-reform over a number of years with little actual improvement in clinical care to patients. Yet the bonus culture has led to side effects that were normally the domain of bankers and financiers.
We have to remember that those high up were carrying out the Government’s Master Plan. That was why they were not sacked but promoted.
This is the central question that the Francis inquiry addressed. Why did a hospital – and, to a dismaying extent, other parts of the NHS – stop being sensitive to patients’ distress? What about consultants doing their ward rounds at
Stafford every day? Did none of them hear the cries and
smell the smells? What about Dr Helen
Moss, the hospital’s director of nursing from 2006 to 2009, the worst
period of neglect? Did she listen to Helene Donnelly, the shocked junior nurse
who outlined her fears about lack of care? Or did Dr Moss believe, as most NHS
managers seem to, that airing the hospital’s dirty linen in public was far
worse than not bothering to change the dirty linen your patients were lying on?
Warning! You may want a gulp of gas and air before you read on. Yesterday, Dr Moss was cleared by her professional regulator. The Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) said that Dr Moss had “no case to answer”. The NMC refused to say how it had reached this remarkable conclusion, since all details of the case are “private”.
So a public servant who was in charge of nursing at a hospital that was complicit in the deaths of 1,200 people is not accountable to the people who paid her wages. If the buck doesn’t stop with Dr Moss, who the hell does it stop with? Certainly not
Stafford’s former chief
executive, Martin Yeates, who cut
150 jobs to save £10 million at a time when there were already serious safety
concerns. An external report recommended that there was a case for disciplinary
action against Mr Yeates, but the hospital board decided on “pragmatic and
commercial grounds” to negotiate terms for an agreed departure. Therefore,
unlike many of his former patients, Mr Yeates left Stafford
hospital not in a wooden box, but with a £400,000 payoff.
Mr Yeates, who resigned with a pay-off of more than £400,000 and a £1 million pension pot from Mid Staffordshire Foundation Trust, which runs the hospital, told the inquiry he was too ill to appear in person.
Bereaved families said they were appalled to learn that Mr Yeates has now taken a job as chief executive of a health charity, Impact Alcohol and Addiction Services, which hold contracts with the NHS.<<<<
Do you need more proof that those involved were part of a master plan? Here they are in the Telegraph:
Cynthia Bower, who was head of the West Midlands strategic health authority at the height of Stafford’s inhumanity, dismissed the hospital’s alarmingly high death rates as “a statistical blip”. Satire lay down and died the day Ms Bower was appointed chief executive of the Care Quality Commission. If you wanted to stop a tragedy like Mid Staffordshire happening ever again, would you really choose a woman who failed to notice the abuse at Mid Staffordshire?
Just for good measure, Sir David Nicholson, who also ran the
West Midlands strategic health authority, is now chief
executive of the entire National Health Service. Small world, isn’t it? A
former Communist, Sir David is said by critics to be the perfect man to ensure
that Stalinist central targets are met, whatever the cost may be.
……What about the midwife who told the Today programme on Tuesday that “you are penalised for taking time to care”.
First Class Clinical Care:
I think that the wonderfully clear language of the NHS’s founders, expressing a profound moral good, has been replaced by management jargon of providers and drivers. That change is not cosmetic. Ugly language has created ugly thinking, with behaviour to match. Too many people going into a British hospital will encounter first-class clinical care in third-world conditions.
Dr Chris Turner told the Francis inquiry that when he started work at Stafford A&E in 2007, the place was “an absolute disaster”. It was so bad that no one could remember what good looked like. The overworked staff were constantly threatened with losing their jobs if they didn’t get patients through the department within the four-hour target. So when John Moore-Robinson was admitted after a cycling accident, he was swiftly diagnosed with bruised ribs and sent away with some painkillers. John died a few hours later from a ruptured spleen, which doctors could have spotted if they’d given the 20-year-old the tests he needed.
So there you have it, master plan or not, patients died unnecessary and those that comply with the Governments plan cuts and targets get promoted.
Medicine as I know no longer exists in many complying hospitals.
Please don’t cry!
© Am Ang Zhang 2012